Where does texture and detail belong? When to stop painting!? How to avoid fiddling? It is a matter of simply reminding yourself as you are painting, there are 3 main areas to your composition. Background, Middleground and Foreground.

3 Main Textural Areas: Background, Middleground, Foreground
Each of these areas is to be handled differently in order to achieve to best illusion of depth and perspective. You want to handle the textural effects judiciously. You’re after a nice smooth, seamless, transition. A gliding walk through the painting rather than a stilted jumpy-bumpy, stop and go ride.
That is the goal, anyway!
Backgrounds in a painting
Backgrounds usually, need to be handled thoughtfully, so that their textures are the calmest and least ‘busy.’
This means with very little variations, textures, contrasts, etc. They need to be kept more on the quiet and subtle side. This can be done with flat washes or even soft graded washes. Wet into wet will work if they are done with cooler, calmer, not bright colours.
Middlegrounds will be just a bit more detailed, a little more of the textural effects and contrasts.

Foregrounds: Will have More Contrast. More Detail.
Foregrounds (generally speaking) are much more textured, brighter coloured, warmer colours, deeper darks, much sharper edges, i.e. “louder.”
The above painting, Watercolour Wild Floral fast and loose! is a good sample of the foreground grabbing the attention with its sharp edges, brightness and contrasting textures.
These textures grab your attention more than the background… as they should, usually. There are exceptions, depending on where the artist/creator intends the viewers’ eyes to go.
The star of the show, the focal point, will of course, have the most texture and detail and contrast of the entire painting, this is in order for it to be the clear and evident Star.
In the below image, you can see how the background area is diffused with less detail, whereas the foreground has more texture, detail, sharper edges and contrast. This is the theory, the plan of what you’d normally want to do in your paintings to create improved depth through the Judicious use of Textures.

This image below, may be just a bit trickier.
In the photo below, if you look closely you will see the 3 divisions – far background, the mid ground and the foreground.
These areas are relatively clear and do follow the guidelines of softer calmer textures in the back. The edges are sharper in front with nice crisp textures and detailing along the paper’s front edge in foreground.

Ways to avoid the Curse of Fiddling
Sometimes, restraint is challenging when you are having so much fun playing with all the colours, textures and techniques.
But, Restraint – is exactly what we need in order to obtain what we desire. Improved paintings. Paintings we ourselves are pleased with.
Judicious use of texture and detail will go a long way to help you create the illusion of depth and perspective you’re aiming for.
Perhaps reminding yourself of 3, 5, 7 ‘rule’ ……… could be a method to help you stop fiddling.
Deliberately count 3 strokes of that fun textural effect, stop. Do 2 more if needed. Stop. and repeat. Less is more.
Also I find by having 2-3+ papers/canvas right in front of me “Waiting” to be Painted! Helps me avoid fiddling and overworking just the one painting.
Counting and setting timers, seem to assist in curbing this Un-helpful habit that ruins my paintings.
Image Below, Watercolour with a Twist, has lovely soft near flatness of texture in the background. The middle ground gets progressively more textured. And the foreground is grooved and sculpted with heaps a gorgeous textural effects from the moulding paste I’d used.

Summary:
- mentally divide painting into the 3 areas back, mid, foreground
- remind yourself often, of the 3 areas, while you are painting
- befriend the word, ‘Restraint’
- make sure you have just one, lone Star of the show
- judiciously count 3, 5, 7 to prevent over doing it
- These suggestions work for most general types of painting, there are some styles, illustrative, graphic design, zentangles, etc. that will naturally follow their own flow.

This is an overhauled, updated version of my Dec. 3, 2014 post.
I felt the subjects of texture, backgrounds, restraint and fiddling to be well worth reposting. With some serious revisions and additions to the original post, here it is. Enjoy!
thank you for reposting – things I will try to keep in mind in my growth process. you are the best teacher!
LikeLiked by 1 person
hi Jodi, thank You!! I enjoy sharing what I’ve learned! and of course hope others won’t have to waste so much money, time, Frustration! grrrrr….. wish I knew then, what I know now 🙂 lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
You should write a book! Thank you. And I love your suggestion to work on several at once to avoid overworking. You’ve mentioned it before, but my memory is like a sieve. 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m thinking of an ebook, when I get time, and when I put a ‘shop’ onto the website. that does sound a lot like procrastination! lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know that feeling well, lol! I hope you do it!
LikeLike
Thank you Debi, this week has been like going to art school, your posted lessons are wonderful. Beautiful samples of your art.
LikeLiked by 2 people
🙂 smiling! MY Pleasure…. I teach art 2-3 x week, so its a foregone conclusion I’m thinking, I obviously just can’t help myself! LOL
LikeLiked by 1 person
I feel like I’m right there a part of your class. Your students are very lucky. 😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
It would be great fun to have you over here too!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the detailed posts. I enjoy reading lessons and the processes of other artists. Lovely art!
LikeLiked by 1 person
hi Jennifer, thank you! same here for your site too! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Why is it whenever I read your posts I want to rush out to the studio and put your words into action. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t know! But I’m glad that they make you want to paint More 🙂 thank you 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love the ‘stop fiddling – less is more’ advice, my god, so flippin true – I find myself talking out loud – “walk away from the work, walk away, no, no don’t even think about it, for the love of god its finished, can’t you see?!!!”
LikeLiked by 1 person
yes Indeed! “WALK AWAY” !! lol
LikeLiked by 1 person